Small fleets pay drivers in one of three ways: a percent of the load, a rate per mile, or a day or week rate, plus extra pay for detention, stops and layovers. Whatever you choose, write it down, and give the driver a settlement sheet each week that lists every load, every deduction and the final pay. Whether a driver is a W-2 employee or a 1099 contractor depends on how the work is really done, not on what you call it.
The three ways to pay
| Method | How it works | Good for | Watch for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percent of the load | The driver gets a share of the load pay, often the linehaul | Pay rises and falls with rates | Decide if fuel surcharge and extra pay are included. Drivers want to see the rate |
| Per mile | A rate per mile, on loaded miles or all miles | Easy to understand and check | Which miles: loaded, all, or routed? Short, slow loads pay less |
| Day or week rate | A set amount a day or week | Local, dedicated or slow runs | You pay even when the truck sits |
Many fleets mix them: per mile plus extra pay for each stop, detention and layover.
Worked example: one week, three ways
A driver ran three loads in a week:
| Load | Linehaul | Loaded miles | Empty miles |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $2,600 | 1,000 | 150 |
| 2 | $1,450 | 520 | 60 |
| 3 | $2,150 | 800 | 120 |
| Total | $6,200 | 2,320 | 330 |
All miles: 2,320 + 330 = 2,650.
| Pay method | Math | Driver's pay |
|---|---|---|
| 28% of linehaul | $6,200 × 28% | $1,736.00 |
| $0.65 per mile, all miles | 2,650 × $0.65 | $1,722.50 |
| $0.72 per loaded mile | 2,320 × $0.72 | $1,670.40 |
The pay is close this week. But in a week of cheap loads, percent pay drops. In a week with lots of empty miles, pay on loaded miles drops. Pick the method that shares the risk the way you want, and say it clearly.
Write the pay agreement down
Before the first load, put this in writing and have the driver sign it:
- How pay is worked out: percent, per mile, or day rate.
- For percent: of what? Linehaul only, or fuel surcharge and extra pay too?
- For per mile: which miles, and from where (the odometer, the ELD, or a routing program)?
- Extra pay: detention, stops, layover, tarping, breakdown time.
- Every deduction, and how each one is worked out.
- The pay week, the cutoff day, and the payday.
Most pay fights come from things nobody wrote down.
The settlement sheet
A settlement is the driver's pay statement for the week. A good one shows:
- The pay week and the payday.
- Each load: date, from and to, miles, rate, and pay for it.
- Each extra: detention, stops, layover.
- Each deduction, with a short reason.
- The final amount paid.
Example: a leased owner-operator's settlement
An owner-operator leased to your company, paid 75% of linehaul plus 100% of fuel surcharge:
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| 75% of linehaul ($6,200) | $4,650.00 |
| Fuel surcharge (100%) | $600.00 |
| Gross | $5,250.00 |
| Fuel bought on the company card | −$1,480.00 |
| Occupational accident insurance | −$45.00 |
| Trailer rental | −$150.00 |
| ELD | −$25.00 |
| Escrow deposit | −$100.00 |
| Total deductions | −$1,800.00 |
| Settlement paid | $3,450.00 |
Rules for leased owner-operators
If owner-operators lease their trucks to your authority, federal Truth-in-Leasing rules apply. From 49 CFR 376.12:
- Pay on time: the lease must say you pay within 15 days after the owner-operator turns in the delivery papers. You can't set a time limit on when they turn them in.
- Deductions: the lease must list every item you may pay first and then take out of their settlement, and how each one is worked out.
- Percent pay: if pay is a percent of the load, you must give them a copy of the rated freight bill or a similar document showing what the load paid.
- Escrow: the lease must say how much escrow you hold and what it can be used for. You account for it, pay interest on it at least every quarter, and return what is left within 45 days after the lease ends.
1099 or W-2?
This is not your choice to make by label. The IRS looks at how the work is actually done, in three areas, on its page on independent contractor or employee:
- Behavior: do you control how, when and where the work is done?
- Money: who owns the truck, pays the costs, and can make or lose money?
- The relationship: is there a contract, benefits, and is the work ongoing and central to your business?
A driver who drives your truck, under your authority, on your schedule, usually looks like an employee. An owner-operator with their own truck, leased under a proper lease, who pays their own costs, usually looks like a contractor. If you are not sure, you or the worker can ask the IRS with Form SS-8. Some states, like California, use a stricter test.
Calling an employee a contractor can bring back taxes and penalties. Ask your tax preparer before you hire.
If the driver is a W-2 employee
You run payroll: you withhold income tax and the employee's Social Security and Medicare, pay your own share, and pay unemployment taxes. See the IRS page on employment taxes. Deductions from an employee's pay must follow federal and state wage laws. A payroll service is often worth it.
If the driver is a 1099 contractor
Get a Form W-9 before the first payment. For payments made in 2026, you give a Form 1099-NEC to each contractor you paid $2,000 or more and file it with the IRS (for payments made in 2025 and earlier, the limit was $600). For 2026 payments, both are due February 1, 2027, because January 31 is a Sunday. See the IRS instructions for Form 1099-NEC. For payments made in 2027, the limit rises to $2,100 (Rev. Proc. 2026-35).
Good habits for paying drivers
- Same pay day every week. Drivers plan around it.
- Send the settlement before the money, so questions come first.
- Keep the papers behind every deduction.
- Never take a deduction that isn't in writing.
- Keep each driver's settlements and year-end total in one place.
Driver pay is often your biggest cost after fuel. Track it by truck in your books; see trucking bookkeeping basics. It is also a deduction on your Schedule C: wages for W-2 drivers, contract labor for 1099 drivers. See owner-operator tax deductions.
How PunjabiTrucker does this
In PunjabiTrucker you set each driver's pay once: percent, per mile or a flat amount, with extra pay and deductions. Settlements build from their loads. The driver sees their own sheet on their phone, in their own language. What each load pays shows only if you allow it. At year end, you have each contractor's total ready for the 1099. See settlements, fleet and what a small fleet needs from its software.
This is general information, not tax or legal advice.
Questions fleet owners ask
What percentage should I pay my truck driver?
There is no set number. It depends on your lanes, your rates, and what the driver pays for. Work out what you need to keep a mile after costs, then set the percent so the driver's pay and your costs both fit inside the load pay.
Is it better to pay drivers by the mile or by percent?
Per mile is easier to check and steadier for the driver. Percent shares the ups and downs of rates. Whichever you choose, say which miles or which part of the load pay counts.
Can I pay a company driver on a 1099?
Only if the driver is really a contractor under the IRS test. A driver in your truck, under your authority, on your schedule usually counts as an employee, so you need payroll.
When do I have to pay a leased owner-operator?
Under 49 CFR 376.12, within 15 days after they turn in the delivery papers. The lease must say so, and must list every deduction.
What is the 1099-NEC limit for 2026?
$2,000, up from $600 for 2025. You give a 1099-NEC to each contractor you paid $2,000 or more in 2026, and file it with the IRS, by February 1, 2027.